Friday, June 26, 2009

Startups and venture capitalists look to profit on Twitter mania

Oprah's doing it. Conan's mocking it. And, as political shockwaves reverberate through Iran, people are relying on it.

Twitter has quickly established itself as a true Internet phenomenon.  And the San Francisco company's meteoric rise -- attracting more than 17 million unique visitors during the month of April alone -- has sparked a new wave of entrepreneurial activity from developers and venture capitalists who think they might just be able to tap into the Twitter ecosystem.

"People are antsy that you have to get in now or you will miss the boat," said Peter Denton, a developer of the Twitter business directory Twibs.

Denton's not alone. Earlier this month, former Microsoft search veteran Ken Moss unveiled a new search application called CrowdEye that's designed to help people more easily find what they're looking for on Twitter. Three days after CrowdEye's launch, VentureBeat looked at 10 other startup companies that are trying to improve the search functionality on Twitter.

Obviously, there's a lot of brain power being spent on solving that one problem alone.

It won't be easy for any of these entrepreneurial ventures to cash in.

After all, Twitter itself -- started as a side project in March 2006 -- has yet to figure out how it will make money from the millions of Tweets flowing through the service each day. At this point, Twitter is just trying to keep up with its growth by offering a stable platform for users.

And while chatter about Twitter's future business model is the subject of endless speculation on blogs and news sites, that's not stopping other entrepreneurial-minded folks from participating in what Denton described as a "land grab."

Some venture capitalists also see opportunity, while others remain cautious.

"Twitter has created a paradigm shift in communication and information discovery by combining various aspects of social-networking, blogging, instant-messaging, e-mail, and search," says Madrona Venture Group's Ayush Agarwal, whose been spending the past few months investigating new ways to create businesses around Twitter.

The Seattle venture capitalist, whose been working closely with Twitter application developer Damon Cortesi, creator of apps such as TweetStats and My First Follow, said that Twitter is part of a much larger trend of what has become known as "real time search."

That's the idea of creating a way for people to discover information as it happens. The flood of information on Twitter after the disputed Iranian elections served as the most recent example of the power of real time search, creating a valuable source of information for those looking for answers.

And while that is one high-profile example, Agarwal said it is "still early days for Twitter."

"There are many opportunities for extending and improving Twitter's functionality, many of which have the potential to create substantive economic value for businesses and consumers," he said. "As a result, we are starting to see more and more developers and VCs looking into this space."

For example, Madrona and others believe there are interesting parallels between Twitter and the way the Internet search business evolved. The key now, he said, is to bring more relevance to the discussion points on Twitter.

"...As the Tweetosphere gets more and more noisy, services which help users isolate the signal from the noise will create a lot of value for users," he said

But not everyone is a believer that the Twitter platform represents a compelling opportunity. 

"I am quite skeptical that one can build a valuable, large scaled and sustaining business on top of someone else's core platform offering," says Bill Bryant, a venture capitalist with Draper Fisher Jurvetson. "It doesn't matter if you're talking about Twitter, Facebook, Salesforce, the iPhone, Windows, Cisco ... the platform will over time absorb the best and highest valued extensions, additions, features, services in its own drive to add value to the broadest set of customers."

A perfect example of this can be seen with the introduction of the new iPhone 3G S. 

Apple, which has opened its platform to thousands of developers, took some of the most popular apps created by outside developers (for example, the landscape keyboard and voice memos) and embedded them into the 3G S. 

And while there may be an occasional break out company that gains momentum on the iPhone, Facebook or Twitter, Bryant thinks those won't happen with much regularity.

"There will be an occasional success story - see Zynga on Facebook for instance -- because the platform vendors need to encourage third parties to continue to build on their offering," he said. "But Zynga is one of (about) 35,000 Facebook applications."

Those are steep odds. Nonetheless, entrepreneurs think it's worth a try.

Appature, a Seattle provider of online marketing tools to healthcare companies, earlier this month introduced Chatterfly to help its customers better manage their brands on Twitter and find relevant information.

At first, Chief Executive Kabir Shahani said he wasn't quite sure if building a Twitter application was worth the company's time. "There is definitely a sense that these things come in waves," he said.

But Shahani became a believer after seeing some of the success that Dell and Comcast reported in terms of interacting with customers through the microblogging service.

"We wanted to get out in front of that, and be able to really help our customers understand the value that they can get out of Twitter from a marketing perspective, and not be left in the forest if you will," he said. "Twitter is what people are asking the most about -- it is the new kid on the block and people are trying to figure out if there is some business value behind this."

Denton, the project manager of Twibs, which is bankrolled by VMware executive Richard McAniff, also is trying to figure out the business value.

more 

Michael Jackson's death swamps Facebook, Twitter, other Internet sites

Reactions to Michael Jackson's death swamped the Internet on Thursday, topping traffic on Twitter and causing huge spikes of visits to Facebook and other Web sites., more 

Big Software Plans for Amazon's Kindle?

, more 

The Family Doctor: A Remedy for Health-Care Costs?

, more 

Ericsson Appoints New CEO

, more 

Thursday, June 25, 2009

Is Bing Travel copying Kayak's popular travel Web site?

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Well, maybe not for the folks at online travel company Kayak.com who are now accusing Microsoft's recently launched Bing Travel service of what essentially amounts to Web site design plagiarism.

Kayak has sent a legal letter to Microsoft asking them to alter the site, with the Norwalk, Connecticut company's chief marketing officer telling Wired that: “from the look and feel of their travel product, they seem to agree with our approach to the market.” (Link via PaidContent.org.)

In an emailed statement, Microsoft spokeswoman Whitney Burk denied that there's any sort of copying going on.

“We are discussing the matter with Kayak," she said. "Bing Travel is based on independent development by Microsoft and Farecast.com, which Microsoft acquired in 2008. Any contrary allegations are without merit.”

The most similar elements appear in the left columns where both sites allow consumers to choose non-stop flights, specific travel times and airlines. Interestingly, Farecast -- the Seattle online travel startup that Microsoft gobbled up last year -- utilized many of those design techniques on its site too.

Still, the rub against Microsoft over the years -- whether in Internet search or software products such as Excel -- is that it operates as a follower of innovative ideas.

Is the software giant doing that now in online travel?

You be the judge. Here's Bing Travel's site:

And here is Kayak's travel site:

[Disclosure: Microsoft Bing is presenting sponsor of the upcoming TechFlash Summer BBQ and Ping-Pong Tournament.]


READ MORE and COMMENT, more 

M2E switches focus, seeks buyer for motion-to-energy technology

In late 2007, OVP Venture Partners led an $8 million investment in a Boise company called M2E Power which had developed a technology to convert a person's movement (walking, running or sitting) into energy that then charged mobile devices. It was a pretty amazing concept in battery charging -- with possible implications for soldiers in battle or those folks who just wanted to charge up their cell phones while on the go.

But it turns out that the mobile device market didn't work as planned, and now M2E is looking for a buyer.

"M2E found that size and mass limitations surrounding the cell phone space were too restrictive, but that some larger form factors (a la vehicular motion) were more promising," OVP's Gerry Langeler tells TechFlash. "While the cell phone opportunity captured attention because it was easy for people to relate to it, the original focus included the larger form factors."

Last December, the company recruited Eric Apfelbach as chief executive. (He's been commuting between Wisconsin and Boise). He wasn't brought on to find a buyer, but Langeler said that he did help discover a potential acquirer. Those talks are in "active discussions," Langeler said.

Earth2Tech's Katie Fehrenbacher broke the news last night and has more details on what is going on at the company, citing a report from researcher and frequent OVP critic Krassen Dimitrov who called M2E's business idea "unworkable due to simple thermodynamic constraints."

In the report, Dimitrov -- who co-founded OVP-backed company NanoString Technologies -- said the $8 million venture round was “another example of irresponsible investment decisions amidst the hype of alternative energy."


READ MORE and COMMENT, more